Corrugated Board vs Plastic, Wood and Solid Board: How to Choose a Transport Packaging Material

No transport packaging material is best for every shipment. Corrugated board is made to the product’s size and suits one-way shipments in dry or controlled conditions, but loses strength as humidity rises. Plastic crates absorb very little water and are built for many trips in a closed loop. Solid wood packaging must be treated and marked under ISPM 15 for most trade outside the EU. Solid board is a dense board without flutes. Choose on the goods, the route, the humidity and the return path. Status as of 13 November 2026.

The four materials at a glance

The table compares the materials by what they are and what to check, not by a ranking. It lists properties described in official and industry sources; for your product, rely on tests rather than on general descriptions.

Material What it is Points in its favour What to check Rules to know
Corrugated board Fluting glued between flat liners; 3-, 5- or 7-ply Made to the product’s dimensions, with inserts and print; one material from box to dividers Strength falls with humidity and under long-term load; built for few rotations Not wood packaging under ISPM 15; cardboard boxes exempt from the PPWR re-use targets
Solid board Dense paper-based board without flutes, single or multi-ply Trade sources describe it as rigid, uniform and puncture-resistant; producers offer moisture-resistant grades for chilled, frozen and wet use Relatively heavy, according to trade sources; ask for the datasheet of the grade The same paper and board rules as corrugated board
Plastic (rigid crates, foldable boxes, bins) Moulded polymer containers, often polypropylene Absorbs very little water; can be washed; designed for many trips Needs a return loop, cleaning and space for empties PPWR re-use targets from 2030 cover plastic crates and foldable plastic boxes; plastics in food contact: Regulation (EU) No 10/2011
Wood (crates, cases, pallets) Solid wood, or processed wood such as plywood, particle board and OSB Used for crates, packing cases and pallets Treatment and marking for export; risk-based checks on wood packaging entering the EU ISPM 15 for solid wood in international trade; pallets are in the PPWR re-use target formats

For the terms, flutes and plies, see cardboard vs corrugated board explained. The FEFCO-ESBO code of box designs, developed by FEFCO and the European Solid Board Organisation, covers cases made of both corrugated and solid board.

Moisture and humidity

Moisture is the main difference between paper-based and plastic packaging. Research on corrugated board shows that higher humidity lowers its mechanical properties, such as stiffness and edge crush resistance, whatever the number of plies, and the US Forest Products Laboratory found that the stacking life of loaded boxes falls as relative humidity rises and when it cycles. Board data are measured after conditioning in the standard atmosphere of ISO 187 (23 °C and 50% relative humidity), so in a damp cold store a box will not deliver its laboratory values. We give no percentages for strength loss, because they depend on the board, the box and the conditions.

For wet or cold chains there are options short of changing material: film-coated or varnished board and moisture-resistant boards with water-based barrier coatings, which we can make or source (see wax-free moisture-resistant corrugated boxes). Test the box in your own conditions before you switch.

Polypropylene, commonly used for reusable plastic containers, absorbs very little water in standard immersion tests, according to material datasheets. Trade sources describe solid board as less sensitive to moisture than corrugated board, and producers offer grades for chilled, frozen and wet use; ask for the datasheet of the grade, not the general description.

Stacking, weight and handling

The stacking strength of a corrugated box depends on the board’s edge crush resistance (ECT) and thickness, the box perimeter and its construction, and it falls under long-term load, more so in humid air. The McKee formula gives only a rough estimate of box compression strength (BCT) for simple boxes; a test gives the proof. For heavy goods there are 5-ply and 7-ply boards; see heavy-duty double-wall AC and triple-wall AAC board.

Whatever the material, compare three things on your own figures: the tare mass per unit, because it counts in the shipping weight and the pallet load; the stacking load the packaging must carry for the whole storage time; and the space empty packaging takes before use and on the way back. A supplier’s general claim is no substitute for a compression, drop or transport simulation test on your product.

Reuse and the PPWR

Regulation (EU) 2025/40 (PPWR) has applied since 12 August 2026. From 1 January 2030, Article 29 sets re-use targets for transport and e-commerce packaging in listed formats, among them pallets, foldable plastic boxes, boxes, trays and plastic crates. Article 29(4)(d) exempts cardboard boxes, and the Commission’s FAQ says this includes corrugated boxes. The legislator explains the exemption in recital 95: for cardboard boxes the number of rotations is very low, while for formats such as pallets, plastic crates and foldable plastic boxes well-functioning reusable alternatives exist.

In practice, plastic crates make sense where the packaging comes back: between your own sites or with regular customers, with someone who collects, inspects and cleans it. For one-way shipments to many recipients, a return loop is hard to run. Returnable corrugated cartons are possible but voluntary; the rules for them are in returnable and reusable shipping cartons under the PPWR. General information, not legal advice.

Wood and ISPM 15

ISPM 15, the international standard of the IPPC, regulates wood packaging material in international trade. As described by the Polish, Belgian, Swedish and Canadian plant protection authorities (as of 13 November 2026):

  • Scope. Wood packaging material means wood or wood products, excluding paper products, used to carry or protect goods, including dunnage. Corrugated board falls outside it.
  • Treatment and mark. Solid wood is heat treated to a core temperature of at least 56 °C for at least 30 minutes, or treated by another approved method, and marked with the IPPC mark and three codes: the country, the producer or treatment facility, and the treatment. Methyl bromide fumigation is not allowed in the EU.
  • Exemptions. Packaging made wholly of processed wood (plywood, particle board, OSB, veneer made with glue, heat or pressure) and wood 6 mm thick or less.
  • Within the EU. The requirement does not generally apply to trade between Member States, with exceptions such as coniferous wood packaging from areas of Portugal and Spain with pine wood nematode. Wood packaging entering the EU from non-EU countries must comply, and export destinations set their own rules.

A corrugated pallet or a box without wooden parts needs no ISPM 15 mark, but a corrugated box on a wooden pallet is only as compliant as the pallet. More on the standard in ISPM 15 for export packaging.

Food contact

Regulation (EC) No 1935/2004 sets the general rules for all food contact materials, and its Annex I lists 17 groups of materials that may get specific measures, among them paper and board, plastics and wood. According to the European Commission, specific EU measures exist for plastics (Regulation (EU) No 10/2011) and a few other materials, but not for paper and board. Whatever the material, ask the supplier for a declaration of conformity that covers your food and use. We have board with a declaration of conformity for direct food contact.

Checklist: what to ask before you choose

  1. Goods. Weight, dimensions, fragility, and whether the goods are wet, oily, frozen or in direct contact with food.
  2. Route. One-way or returning? Domestic, within the EU or outside it (ISPM 15 for wood)?
  3. Climate. Storage time, temperature, relative humidity and condensation risk at each stage.
  4. Stacking. Stack height and load over the whole storage time; ask for test data, not a general claim.
  5. Return loop. If the packaging comes back: who collects, inspects, cleans and stores it, and who pays for the return transport?
  6. Rules. Do the PPWR re-use targets apply to the format, and is the food contact declaration for your use?
  7. Disposal. What happens to the packaging at the end: a carton made only of board can be put in the paper collection container, while coatings, laminates and mixed materials need a separate check.

What we make, and what we do not

We make packaging from corrugated board only: 3-ply E, B and C; 5-ply EB, BE, BC and the heavy AC; 7-ply AAC, also in special compositions. Die-cut boxes are made up to 260 × 150 cm, large boxes up to 10 × 3 m and telescopic boxes many metres long. We also make corrugated pallets, dividers and inserts, film-coated and varnished boards, and can supply antistatic (ESD) board. We do not make solid board or plastic and wooden packaging; foam or plastic inserts are only possible with partners. Board data come from our suppliers’ tests for each batch, and package tests can be arranged in a partner laboratory on individually agreed terms. We tailor order quantities to your needs – we also make short runs and prototypes. If a construction requires a minimum quantity, we state it in the quote. Most orders are delivered within 7 days (max. 16 working days); delivery in the EU is by arrangement.

Sources

Regulation (EU) 2025/40 on EUR-Lex (Articles 29 and 71, recital 95); Polish plant protection authority (PIORiN) on wood packaging; Belgian food safety agency (FASFC) on EU rules for wood packaging; European Commission on food contact materials legislation. On humidity: Mrówczyński and others, Applied Sciences, 2024, and Urbanik and Lee, Wood and Fiber Science, 1995. Check the current texts before you decide.

What to send us

Tell us what you pack now, the product’s weight and dimensions, the route, the storage conditions and whether the packaging comes back. We will propose a corrugated construction or tell you if another material fits better. Send your enquiry through our home page.

Frequently asked questions

Which transport packaging material is best: corrugated board, plastic, wood or solid board?

None is best for every case. Corrugated board is made to the product’s dimensions and suits one-way shipments in dry or controlled conditions. Plastic crates and boxes absorb very little water and are built for many trips in a loop where the packaging comes back and is cleaned. Solid wood packaging must be treated and marked under ISPM 15 for most trade outside the EU. Solid board is a dense board without flutes. Decide on the goods, the route, the humidity and whether the packaging returns.

Is corrugated board weaker in humid conditions?

Yes. Research on corrugated board shows that higher humidity lowers its mechanical properties, and the stacking life of loaded boxes falls as relative humidity rises and when it cycles. We give no percentages, because they depend on the board, the box and the conditions. For cold or wet chains, ask about moisture-resistant boards and test the box in your own conditions.

Do corrugated boxes and corrugated pallets need ISPM 15 treatment?

No. ISPM 15 covers wood packaging material, which official plant health authorities define as wood or wood products excluding paper products. Packaging made only of corrugated board falls outside that definition. A corrugated box shipped on a wooden pallet still needs a compliant pallet wherever the destination requires ISPM 15.

Does ISPM 15 apply to wooden packaging moving within the EU?

Generally not. The Polish, Belgian and Swedish plant protection authorities state that the requirement does not generally apply to wood packaging moving between EU Member States, with exceptions such as coniferous wood packaging from areas of Portugal and Spain with pine wood nematode. Wood packaging entering the EU from non-EU countries must comply, and most export destinations require it. Status as of 13 November 2026.

Will the PPWR force me to replace cardboard boxes with reusable plastic crates?

Not for cardboard boxes. From 1 January 2030, Article 29 of Regulation (EU) 2025/40 sets re-use targets for transport packaging in formats such as pallets, plastic crates and foldable plastic boxes, but Article 29(4)(d) exempts cardboard boxes, and the Commission’s FAQ says this includes corrugated boxes. Plastic crates and pallets are not covered by that exemption. General information, not legal advice.

What is solid board, and do you make it?

Solid board, or solid fibreboard, is a dense paper-based board without flutes, made of one or more plies. We do not make solid board. We make packaging from corrugated board in 3-, 5- and 7-ply grades, and where a premium surface is needed we use printing, lamination, varnish or foil coating.

Can corrugated packaging be used for food?

Yes, if the board is suitable for the use. We have board with a declaration of conformity for direct food contact. Paper and board have no specific EU measure and fall under framework Regulation (EC) No 1935/2004; plastics are also covered by Regulation (EU) No 10/2011. Ask for the declaration that covers your use.

Can you replace our wooden or plastic packaging with corrugated packaging?

We can propose a corrugated construction and have it tested. Send us the product, its weight and dimensions, the route and the storage conditions. We make boxes up to 10 × 3 m, die-cut boxes up to 260 × 150 cm, heavy AC and AAC boards and corrugated pallets. We state no load capacity in kg without a test; package tests can be arranged in a partner laboratory on individually agreed terms.