Plastic-Free Protection for E-commerce: Corrugated Mailers and Paper Cushioning vs Bubble and Padded Mailers
For many e-commerce shipments, a corrugated envelope or mailer sized to the product, with a die-cut corrugated insert or paper cushioning where needed, can replace bubble mailers, air pillows and foam. Whether it protects as well depends on the product and the route, so test it, for example to ISTA 3A, before you switch. The PPWR does not ban bubble wrap, but from 2030 at the earliest it counts any filling material, paper included, as empty space. Status 13 November 2026; general information, not legal advice.
Start with the format, not the filler
A pack that closes around the product needs little or no filling. The table compares common formats for single parcels; it describes typical uses, not test results.
| Format | Typical contents | How it protects | Materials | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Corrugated envelope (flat mailer of E or B flute board) | Printed matter, books, catalogues, textiles, flat parts | Board stiffness keeps the item flat; the flute takes light knocks | Board and paper; adhesive strip and tear strip as specified | Not for fragile or thick items |
| Adjustable-height mailer (crease lines, or an open-flute lining facing the product) | Items of varying thickness, cosmetics in rigid packs | Creases let the mailer close around the item; the open flute acts as a cushion | Board and paper | The height range depends on the construction: agree it on a sample |
| Mailer box (FEFCO 0427), with or without a die-cut insert | Small rigid products, gift and subscription boxes | Rigid walls; an insert holds the product away from them | Board | Needs a cutting die; the insert must fit the product |
| Slotted box (for example FEFCO 0201) with inserts or paper cushioning | Glass, ceramics, electronics, mixed orders | Inserts suspend the product, or cushioning fills the space around it | Board and paper | Loose filling counts as empty space under Article 24 of the PPWR |
| Bubble or padded mailer | Small items, accessories, spare parts | Air cells or padding absorb knocks | Plastic film, or paper combined with a plastic bubble layer | The PPWR rules for plastic apply |
| Plastic mailer bag | Apparel and other soft goods | No cushioning; the film keeps out dirt and water | Plastic film | Minimum recycled content for plastic packaging from 2030 at the earliest |
As a general guide, corrugated envelopes and mailers suit flat and light products. For glass, ceramics and electronics a mailer alone is usually not enough: use a box with an insert or cushioning, and test it. For tape-free mailer boxes see our article on FEFCO 0427 corrugated mailers. If the parcel goes into a locker, measure the outer dimensions after closing and compare them with the parcel locker sizes by country.
Paper-based cushioning compared with bubble wrap and air pillows
Single-face corrugated board, one flat liner glued to one fluted paper, is often used for mailer linings and paper wraps: the open flute faces the product and takes the shock. The last column shows whether Article 24(3) of the PPWR names the material as a filling material.
| Option | How it works | Named as filling material in Article 24(3)? |
|---|---|---|
| Die-cut corrugated insert (cradle, partitions, corner pieces) | Holds the product in place and away from the walls | Not named; the methodology is not yet published |
| Corrugated strips, lattices, rolled board | Fill gaps, separate items, absorb knocks | Not named; loose pieces may be treated like filling |
| Honeycomb paper (pads or expanding wrap) | Paper cells cushion and wrap | Not named; used loose, it may be treated like filling |
| Crumpled or cut paper | Fills voids and stops movement | Yes (paper cuttings) |
| Bubble wrap, air pillows | Air cells absorb knocks and fill voids | Yes (bubble wraps, air cushions) |
| Foam, polystyrene chips | Compress under impact | Yes (foam fillers, polystyrene, Styrofoam chips) |
Cushioning is designed from two inputs: the fragility of the product, that is, the shock it can withstand, expressed in G, and the cushion curves of the material. A cushion curve plots the peak acceleration transmitted at a given drop height and thickness against the static loading, which is the weight of the product divided by the area of contact. ASTM D1596 is a common test method for these curves. Supplier curves do not replace a test of the finished pack. For a full comparison of void fill and inserts see void fill and product protection compared.
What the PPWR changes, and what it does not
Regulation (EU) 2025/40 has applied since 12 August 2026. These provisions matter most for the choice between plastic and paper protection, as of 13 November 2026.
| Provision | Article | When | What it means for this choice |
|---|---|---|---|
| Maximum empty space ratio of 50% in grouped, transport and e-commerce packaging; space filled by filling materials (paper cuttings, air cushions, bubble wraps, foam fillers, polystyrene and others) counts as empty space | 24(1) and (3) | 1 January 2030 or 3 years after the implementing acts on the methodology (due by 12 February 2028), whichever is later | Swapping bubble wrap for paper does not change the ratio; a smaller pack does. The obligation lies with the operator who fills the packaging |
| Exemption for sales packaging used as e-commerce packaging and for reusable packaging within a re-use system | 24(5) | As above | Such packaging must still meet Article 10 |
| Weight and volume reduced to the minimum necessary for functionality; no double walls, false bottoms or unnecessary layers that only increase perceived volume | 10 | By 1 January 2030 | Applies to the manufacturer or importer of the packaging |
| Restricted packaging formats listed in Annex V | 25 | From 1 January 2030 | The six listed formats do not include bubble wrap, air pillows or plastic mailers |
| Minimum recycled content in plastic parts of packaging: 35% for plastic packaging outside the contact-sensitive and bottle categories, 65% from 2040; plastic parts under 5% of the weight of the packaging unit are exempt | 7(1)(d), 7(2)(d) and 7(5)(b) | 1 January 2030 or 3 years after the implementing act on the calculation (due by 31 December 2026), whichever is later | Ask suppliers of plastic mailers how they will meet it |
| All packaging recyclable; recyclability performance grades A, B or C | 6 | Design for recycling from 1 January 2030 or 24 months after the delegated acts, whichever is later | Ask how combinations of materials, such as paper with a plastic bubble layer, will be graded |
The empty-space rule is often misread: paper void fill counts as empty space just like plastic filling, so the real lever is the size of the pack (see right-sizing boxes). For all PPWR dates and obligations see the PPWR checklist for packaging buyers. Neither the methodology under Article 24(2) nor the implementing act under Article 7(8) had appeared in EUR-Lex on 13 November 2026.
How to prove protection before you switch
- Describe the product. Weight, dimensions, fragile points and, if you know it, its fragility in G.
- Build samples. For example an envelope, a mailer with an insert and a box with paper cushioning.
- Test in a laboratory. ISTA 3A is a general simulation test for individual packaged products of 70 kg (150 lb) or less shipped through parcel delivery systems. ISTA 3 series tests combine shaped random vibration, drops from different heights and, where chosen, atmospheric conditioning. The ISTA 6 series has procedures written for the supply chains of individual retailers and carriers, if a marketplace asks for one.
- Allow for humidity. Corrugated board loses compression strength as it takes up moisture: for cold or damp routes, include conditioning in the test.
- Run pilot shipments. Send a batch on your real routes and compare damage and returns with your current packaging. Decide on this data, not on slogans.
Claims you can and cannot print
Directive (EU) 2024/825 adds to the list of banned commercial practices towards consumers, among others: generic environmental claims without recognised excellent environmental performance (Annex I, point 4a, of Directive 2005/29/EC), claims about the whole product when they concern only one aspect (point 4b) and presenting requirements imposed by law as a distinctive feature (point 10a), such as advertising PPWR compliance. Member States were to apply their rules from 27 September 2026, but national transposition differs, so check each country you sell to.
- State facts. Write what the pack is made of, for example a corrugated board mailer with paper cushioning, not a general slogan.
- Check plastic-free. It must be true for the whole pack: ask what the adhesive strip, release liner, tear strip, tape, labels and any coating are made of.
- Give disposal facts. A carton made only of board can be put in the paper collection container. For mailers with plastic tape, windows, laminates or coatings, check before you say so.
Checklist: what to ask your supplier
- Which board (flute, single-face or double-face) and which construction do you propose for my product, and why?
- What height range does the adjustable mailer cover, measured on a sample with my product?
- Does the insert keep the product away from all walls, and how quickly can it be packed?
- What are all components made of (adhesive strip, release liner, tear strip, print, coating)?
- Which test procedure, which laboratory, who pays and what counts as a pass?
- What are the outer dimensions after closing, for carrier and locker limits?
- Does the pack need a cutting die or printing plate, and what are the order quantities and lead time?
What we can do
We make corrugated envelopes, mailer boxes and boxes to your dimensions, with die-cut corrugated inserts, dividers and lattices in any size. On request we make fillers from corrugated strips, honeycomb and rolled board, and we can make or source open-flute paper mailers with adjustable height. In cooperation with partners we supply honeycomb paper cushioning and foam inserts, also to customers in the EU. Our boards: 3-layer E, B and C; 5-layer EB, BE, BC and heavy AC; 7-layer AAC. We print digitally, including UV, and match Pantone colours. We can arrange package tests (compression, drop, transport simulation) in a partner laboratory; terms are agreed individually. We do not promise that paper protects as well as bubble wrap: that has to be tested on your product. We tailor order quantities to your needs – we also make short runs and prototypes. If a construction requires a minimum quantity, we state it in the quote. Most orders are delivered within 7 days (max. 16 working days); delivery within the EU by arrangement.
Sources
Regulation (EU) 2025/40 on EUR-Lex (Articles 6, 7, 10, 24, 25 and 71, Annex V); Directive (EU) 2024/825 on EUR-Lex (Article 4 and Annex); ISTA test procedures; ASTM D1596. Check the current texts before you decide.
What to send us
Tell us the product, its weight and dimensions, how fragile it is, how it ships (courier or parcel locker), your current packaging and the expected quantities. We produce boxes to your dimensions. Send your enquiry through our home page.
Frequently asked questions
Does the PPWR ban bubble wrap or plastic mailers?
No. Article 25 and Annex V of Regulation (EU) 2025/40 restrict six packaging formats from 1 January 2030, and bubble wrap, air pillows and plastic mailers are not among them. Plastic packaging does face other rules, such as minimum recycled content (Article 7) and recyclability (Article 6). Status 13 November 2026; general information, not legal advice.
Does switching to paper void fill help with the 50% empty-space limit?
No. Article 24(3) counts space filled by filling materials, paper cuttings included, as empty space, just like air cushions and bubble wrap. What lowers the ratio is a smaller box or a mailer that closes around the product. The limit applies from 1 January 2030 at the earliest, to the operator who fills the packaging.
Do die-cut corrugated inserts count as empty space?
The Regulation does not settle this. Inserts are not named in the list of filling materials in Article 24(3), and the methodology for the calculation, due by 12 February 2028, had not appeared in EUR-Lex on 13 November 2026. Do not assume either answer until it is published.
Does a corrugated mailer protect as well as a bubble mailer?
We do not promise that. It depends on the product, the board and the construction, and independent comparisons are scarce. Test the new pack on your product, for example to ISTA 3A, and run pilot shipments on your real routes before you switch.
Which products suit a corrugated envelope or mailer?
Mainly flat and light products: printed matter, books, catalogues, textiles, flat parts and cosmetics in rigid packs. Glass, ceramics and electronics usually need a box with a die-cut insert or cushioning, and a test.
Can I print plastic-free or an environmental slogan on the mailer?
Plastic-free is a specific claim, so it must be true for the whole pack, including the adhesive strip, release liner, tear strip, labels and any coating. Under Directive (EU) 2024/825, generic environmental claims to consumers are banned unless the trader can demonstrate recognised excellent environmental performance. Check the rules in each country you sell to.
Can a corrugated mailer go into paper collection?
A carton made only of board can be put in the paper collection container. If the mailer has plastic tape, a window, a laminate or a coating, check the local collection rules before you tell your customers so.
Can you make corrugated mailers and paper cushioning?
Yes. We make corrugated envelopes, mailer boxes and boxes to your dimensions with die-cut inserts, and on request fillers from corrugated strips, honeycomb and rolled board. We can make or source open-flute mailers with adjustable height. In cooperation with partners we supply honeycomb paper cushioning and foam inserts, also to customers in the EU. Package tests can be arranged in a partner laboratory on individually agreed terms.