Void Fill and Product Protection Compared: Paper, Corrugated Inserts, Air Pillows and Foam

Void fill stops a product from moving, cushioning absorbs shocks, and inserts, dividers and lattices hold each item in place. Paper fill suits light, sturdy goods; air pillows add little weight but can puncture; foam cushions fragile items but adds a second material; corrugated inserts locate and separate products in the same material as the box. Under Article 24 of the PPWR, filled space counts as empty space, so the strongest lever is a box that fits. As of 13 November 2026; general information, not legal advice.

Three jobs: filling, cushioning and holding

Decide first what the protection has to do. Filling takes up free space so that the product cannot slide. Cushioning absorbs the energy of a drop or vibration. Holding fixes each item in a defined position, away from other items and from the box walls. A loose filler is not a structure: a heavy item can push through it to the wall of the box. A fitted insert, in turn, cannot make up for a box that is far too big. Start from the product: weight, shape, fragile points and the number of items per box.

Comparison of the main options

Option What it does Suits Watch out for Article 24 of the PPWR
Paper void fill (crumpled or folded paper, pads) Fills gaps, limits movement Light, sturdy products; orders that vary in content Loosely packed paper settles; limited protection for heavy or fragile items Filling material: counts as empty space
Corrugated inserts, dividers and lattices Hold the product in place, separate items Bottles, jars, glass, electronics, sets of parts, repeat shipments Made for one product and one box; a new construction needs a prototype Not named; depends on the methodology
Paper honeycomb, board strips, rolled board Buffers, edge and corner protection Larger or heavier items Designed per product Not named; the list is open (“such as”), so not settled
Air pillows and bubble wrap Fill gaps or cover surfaces, little added weight Light products; shipments charged by dimensional weight Sharp edges and heavy items puncture or crush them; plastic film to sort Named: counts as empty space
Foam, including expanded polystyrene (loose, sheets, shaped inserts) Cushions shocks; shaped inserts also hold the product Fragile, heavy or high-value devices A second material for the recipient to separate; shaped inserts need a tool Foam fillers and polystyrene chips named; shaped foam inserts not addressed

The table describes typical uses, not performance: the result depends on the whole packed box, so confirm the choice with a test. For corrugated mailers and paper cushioning in e-commerce, see plastic-free protection for e-commerce.

What Article 24 of the PPWR says about empty space

Regulation (EU) 2025/40 (PPWR) has applied since 12 August 2026. Status as of 13 November 2026:

Rule Article When Who
Maximum empty space ratio of 50% in grouped, transport and e-commerce packaging 24(1) From 1 January 2030 or 3 years after the methodology acts enter into force, whichever is later Operators who fill such packaging
Calculation methodology, taking into account irregular shapes, several products in one pack, liquids, easily damaged products, small products that larger ones can damage, and space for shipping labels 24(2) Due by 12 February 2028; not found in EUR-Lex on 13 November 2026 European Commission
Empty space = total volume minus the volume of the sales packaging inside; space filled by filling materials counts as empty space 24(3) With the limit The calculation
Sales packaging: empty space reduced to the minimum necessary, including for product protection; no fixed percentage 24(4) By 12 February 2028 Operators who fill sales packaging
No 50% limit for sales packaging used as e-commerce packaging or for reusable packaging within a re-use system 24(5) With the limit Operators using such packaging

For void fill this means that paper, air pillows, bubble wrap and foam fillers do not reduce the ratio: a box that is half full of paper is, for the calculation, half empty. The text does not name die-cut corrugated inserts or dividers and subtracts only the volume of sales packaging, so do not count on an insert to lower the ratio until the methodology is published. What lowers it is a smaller box that still protects the product: see right-sizing corrugated boxes and dimensional weight.

Article 10 also requires packaging weight and volume to be reduced to the minimum necessary for its function from 1 January 2030, and the first performance criterion in Annex IV is product protection. Protection the product really needs is therefore a valid design reason; record why you chose it. For the full timeline see the PPWR checklist for packaging buyers.

Example: sizing a lattice (illustration, not an offer)

One cell = (inside dimension − (cells in the row − 1) × board thickness) ÷ cells in the row. For a box with inside dimensions of 300 × 200 mm and a 3 × 2 lattice of 3-layer B-flute board about 3 mm thick: (300 − 2 × 3) ÷ 3 = 98 mm by (200 − 3) ÷ 2 = 98.5 mm. Make the cell slightly larger than the product’s cross-section so that items go in without force, and the partitions high enough to protect the widest part; for bottles, usually at least up to the shoulders.

How to choose

  1. Box size first. Pick the smallest box that leaves room for the protection the product needs.
  2. Weight and fragility. Light, sturdy goods often need only firm filling; fragile, heavy or high-value goods need a designed insert or cushioning, confirmed by a test.
  3. Several items per box. Separate them with dividers or a lattice so they cannot hit each other.
  4. Repeat or mixed orders. The same product shipped again and again suits a fitted insert; changing orders suit flexible fill or a range of box sizes.
  5. Packing time and the recipient. Time each option on your own line. A box with inserts made only of board can go in the paper collection container; plastic fillers and foam must be separated under local rules.

Testing the protection

Compare options on the packed box, not on the material. Common methods: ISTA 3A (2018 edition), a simulation test for individual packaged products up to 70 kg shipped by parcel delivery; ISO 4180:2019, general rules for test schedules for complete, filled transport packages; ISO 2248:1985, the drop test; ISO 12048:1994, compression and stacking tests. A standard describes a method, not a certificate. Agree the sequence, the number of samples and the pass criteria before testing. We can arrange package tests (compression, drop, transport simulation) in a partner laboratory; terms are agreed individually. If shipments already arrive damaged, see why cartons get damaged in transit.

Checklist: what to ask your supplier

  1. Which dimensions, weight, fragile points and number of items per box does the proposal assume?
  2. Which element fills, which cushions and which holds the product, and why is each needed?
  3. What is each element made of, and can the recipient dispose of everything as one material?
  4. Is there a smaller box that still protects the product?
  5. Does the insert need a cutting tool or a mould, and can you test a prototype first?
  6. Which test method and pass criteria, and who carries out the test?

What we can make

We make dividers, lattices, inserts and fillers from corrugated board in any size, die-cut to your product, box or pallet, and fillers from strips, honeycomb and rolled board on request. In cooperation with partners we also offer foam or plastic inserts and honeycomb fillers, for customers in the EU too, and combine them with our boxes and board elements. Boards: 3-layer E, B and C; 5-layer EB, BE, BC and heavy AC; 7-layer AAC. We propose the board and construction in the quote and make prototypes of new constructions. We state no level of protection in advance. We tailor order quantities to your needs – we also make short runs and prototypes. If a construction requires a minimum quantity, we state it in the quote.

Sources

Regulation (EU) 2025/40 on EUR-Lex (Articles 10, 24 and 71, Annex IV); Commission guidance document for the PPWR (10 June 2026); Commission FAQ on the PPWR (3 August 2026); ISTA 3A overview; ISO 4180:2019; ISO 2248:1985; ISO 12048:1994. Check the current texts before you decide.

What to send us

Tell us the product, its dimensions, weight and fragile points, the number of items per box and how it is shipped; add a photo or drawing if you have one. Send your enquiry through our home page.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between void fill and cushioning?

Void fill takes up free space so that the product cannot move. Cushioning absorbs shocks and vibration. Inserts, dividers and lattices hold each item in a fixed position and keep items apart. Many shipments need more than one of these jobs.

Does paper void fill count as empty space under the PPWR?

Yes. Article 24(3) of Regulation (EU) 2025/40 says that space filled by filling materials, such as paper cuttings, air cushions, bubble wraps, sponge fillers, foam fillers, wood wool, polystyrene or Styrofoam chips, is considered empty space. Filling a large box with paper does not lower its empty space ratio.

Do corrugated inserts and dividers count as empty space?

The Regulation does not say. Article 24(3) does not name inserts or dividers among the filling materials, and the calculation methodology is due from the Commission by 12 February 2028; we did not find it in EUR-Lex on 13 November 2026. Do not assume that an insert lowers the ratio.

When does the 50% empty space limit apply?

From 1 January 2030 or 3 years after the entry into force of the implementing acts on the methodology, whichever is later (Article 24(1)), for grouped, transport and e-commerce packaging. Sales packaging used as e-commerce packaging and reusable packaging within a re-use system are exempt (Article 24(5)). General information, not legal advice.

Who is responsible for the empty space ratio: the box maker or the company that packs?

The company that fills the packaging. Article 24(1) places the obligation on economic operators who fill grouped, transport or e-commerce packaging. A box maker can help you choose the size and the insert, but the ratio depends on what goes into the box.

Are air pillows better than paper void fill?

Neither is better in general. Air pillows add little weight, but sharp edges and heavy items can puncture or crush them, and the recipient has plastic film to sort. Paper has to be packed firmly or it settles. For both, the PPWR counts the filled space as empty space.

Can you make inserts, dividers and fillers to measure?

Yes. We make dividers, lattices, inserts and fillers from corrugated board in any size, die-cut to the product and the box, and fillers from strips, honeycomb and rolled board on request. In cooperation with partners we also offer foam or plastic inserts and honeycomb fillers, for customers in the EU too. We state no level of protection in advance; we can arrange package tests in a partner laboratory, with terms agreed individually.