ECT, BCT and the McKee Formula: How to Estimate Box Stacking Strength

Two numbers appear in almost every technical conversation about corrugated boxes: ECT and BCT. They are often confused, but they answer different questions. ECT tells you how strong the board is. BCT tells you how much top-to-bottom load a finished box can carry. The McKee formula links the two, and it is the quickest way to judge whether a board grade is realistic for your stack before you order or test anything.

ECT and BCT in one minute

  • ECT (edge crush test) is a property of the board: the force per unit length that a strip of board withstands when it is compressed on its edge (ISO 3037). It is quoted in kN/m.
  • BCT (box compression test) is a property of the finished box: the force it withstands when it is compressed top to bottom in a compression tester (see ISO 12048 for complete, filled packages). It is quoted in newtons or kilonewtons.

Typical board data

Board ECT (kN/m) Thickness
3-layer E 3 to 5.5 about 1.5 mm
3-layer B 3 to 6 2 to 3 mm
3-layer C 4 to 6.5 3.5 to 4 mm
5-layer EB 7 to 9 3.5 to 4 mm
5-layer BC 5.5 to 9 (heavy grades up to about 15) 5.5 to 6.5 mm

These are typical ranges from board datasheets. The exact value depends on the paper grades used, so always specify the ECT you need.

The McKee formula

The McKee formula, published in 1963, estimates box compression strength from the board and the box perimeter. In metric units the simplified form is:

BCT (N) ≈ 5.87 × ECT (kN/m) × √(thickness (mm) × perimeter (mm))

The perimeter is the distance around the base of the box: 2 × (length + width). The constant 5.87 comes from the original formula, and it stays the same when ECT is in kN/m and the lengths are in millimetres. Height does not appear in the simplified form.

A worked example (arithmetic only)

Take a regular slotted box with a base of 400 × 300 mm, so the perimeter is 1,400 mm, in single-wall board. Using the low and the high end of the ranges above:

Board Estimated BCT Roughly in kgf
3-layer E 0.8 to 1.5 kN 80 to 150
3-layer B 0.9 to 2.3 kN 95 to 230
3-layer C 1.6 to 2.9 kN 170 to 290

This is an illustration of the arithmetic from datasheet ranges, not a specification or a guarantee. The low-to-high spread shows why the exact grade matters.

From BCT to a safe stack

BCT is the load at which a new, dry box fails in a test. A stack carries the load for days or weeks, in changing humidity, so engineers apply a safety factor. As an illustration, take the low value for 3-layer C, 1.6 kN, and a safety factor of 3. A filled box of 10 kg exerts about 98 N, so the bottom box can carry about 1,640 ÷ (3 × 98) ≈ 5 boxes above it, a stack of 6. The right factor depends on storage time, humidity and handling, so treat 3 as an example, not a rule. To see how boxes line up on a pallet, read how many boxes fit on a pallet.

Where the formula stops working

  • It fits regular slotted boxes of typical proportions best; for the construction, compare FEFCO 0201 vs 0203.
  • Cut-outs, handholes and windows weaken a box.
  • Humidity and long storage lower the real strength.
  • Columns that are not aligned, or pallet overhang, reduce the load a stack can carry.
  • Double-wall boards need care: the simplified form is a rough guide, and a compression test is the proof.

How to choose

Start from the stack: the weight of one filled box, how many levels, and how long it stands. Then pick a grade whose estimated BCT, after the safety factor, covers it. For flutes and board grades, see how to choose corrugated boxes in bulk.

What to send us

Send the box size, the weight of the filled box, the stacking height and the storage conditions. We produce boxes to your dimensions and advise on the grade. Read the guide to buying cardboard boxes from Poland and our wholesale terms, and send your enquiry through our home page.

See also: Heavy-Duty Corrugated Board: Double-Wall AC and Triple-Wall AAC Explained

See also: Corrugated Archive Boxes: Constructions, Board, Sizing for Binders and Labelling

See also: Tolerances on Corrugated Boxes: Dimensions, Creases, Grammage and Delivered Quantity – What Is Normal and How to Specify It

See also: Cardboard vs Corrugated Board: How Corrugated Board Is Made, and What Flutes, Liners and Grammage Mean

See also: How to Store Corrugated Boxes: Humidity, Temperature, Stacking and Stock Rotation

Frequently asked questions

What is ECT?

ECT is the edge crush test: the force per unit length that a strip of corrugated board withstands when compressed on its edge, measured to ISO 3037. It describes the board, not the finished box.

What is BCT and how is it different from ECT?

BCT is the box compression test: the top-to-bottom force that a finished box withstands in a compression tester. ECT is a property of the board; BCT is a property of the box made from it, and it also depends on the box size and how it is built.

Does the McKee formula replace a compression test?

No. It is an estimate for regular slotted boxes. Cut-outs, unusual proportions, humidity and poor stacking alignment all reduce real strength, so critical loads should be tested.

Which board grade should I choose for my stack?

Tell us the size, the weight of the filled box, the stacking height and how long the stack stands. We advise on a grade that matches the load.